Chocolate Oyster is a retro-scripted, observational film, following two twenty-somethings, Ellie (Anna Lawrence) and Taylor (Rosie Lourde), as they pursue unobtainable lives promised to them by pop culture. Following Ellie and Taylor around Sydney to various galleries, dinners, and dancing, the girls expose their vulnerabilities and their true natures are revealed. Faced with reality, Ellie and Taylor are forced to choose between standing still or getting their shit together.